Maddie

How are your prices so affordable? What's the catch?

Recent changes in e-commerce strategy has left warehouses filled with brand-new, trendy, and high-value shoes. These shoes are in perfect condition, ready to wear, and totally on-trend.

The issue? Big retailers don’t want to deal with the hassle of sorting and selling them individually—and that’s where Shoes for Dinner steps in. We grab these hidden gems and pass the savings directly to you—no fluff, just unbeatable prices.

Why Mystery Boxes?

With up to 5 pairs in each Mystery Box, we can streamline our fulfillment process and save on shipping costs...which ultimately means that we can deliver jaw-dropping deals on high-quality, high-MSRP shoes.

• We offer free ground shipping on all $59+ orders in the continental US.
• All other orders will have calculated rates added at checkout, determined by the size of your order and your shipping location.
• If you qualify for (and select) free shipping, we will ship your order in the most cost-effective method available. If need your order sooner, please select one of the faster paid options available at checkout.
• All orders are shipped within 3-5 business days. You will receive an email notification with tracking information once your order has shipped.
• Mystery boxes are shipped without original retail boxes to save space and reduce waste. Individual Pairs will have their original shoe box included.
• Depending on how many pairs of shoes you ordered, your order may arrive in multiple boxes.
• Please doublecheck the shipping address you enter at checkout. SFD cannot be help responsible for items shipped to an incorrectly entered address. If you realized that you entered your address incorrectly after you checked out, please email us immediately at hello@shoesfordinner.com, and we’ll do our best to update the shipping information before it goes out.
• At this time, we do not offer international shipping.

• Because of the nature of our model (and the truly insane deals we offer), all sales are final. We hope you understand that in offering these beyond-good prices, we’re also keeping waste low, wardrobes fresh, and feet stylish.
• All Mystery Boxes are final sale and not eligible for returns or exchanges. These boxes are deeply discounted and curated with care to offer amazing value, all while helping us reduce fashion waste by giving brand-new shoes a second life.
• For individual items not part of a mystery box, you may request store credit if your return is approved. Because our inventory is limited and sizes may not restock, we offer store credit only to keep things flexible and fair for all shoppers.
• You can view our full return & exchange policy here.